Sunday, May 22, 2011

Fab Friends & Stuffed Shells

I am blessed with some really, really wonderful friends.  Let me share with you a little bit about 2 of them.

"My" Sandy was my babysitter from the time I was 6 weeks old up until I went to school.  I was the flower girl in both of her daughter's weddings, went on vacations with their family, babysat the grandchildren, and so on.  They are all like family to me.  My Sandy loves the color red.  I couldn't help but think of her when I selected red for my first Le Creuset item, setting the standard for many more items to come!  Just a few weeks after I made that purchase I opened my front door to a package marked "Chef's" on the side.  What a fantastic surprise it was to find a red, rectangular Le Creuset covered casserole dish from My Sandy inside!  I was so excited, thrilled, and especially touched to have received such a nice gift from My Sandy, thank you so much!

Here's what it looks like:

Another good friend of mine is Deanna.  She's also Pittsburgh girl who lives in Hawaii.  She was a pierogi with me for Halloween, demanded that we have our own fish fry, and even re-made my upside down pizza casserole and sent me photos.  Deanna volunteered to take care of my cat, Bagheera, for my upcoming trip to the mainland.  Being one of my blog's biggest supporters, Deanna read the cannoli post and admitted to me that she's never seen the Godfather.  Could we still be friends?  Yes.  Although she had to see it, and right away!  Today, Deanna came over to meet Bagheera, watch the Godfather, and grub!

I used my fabulous new casserole dish from My Sandy to make dinner for Deanna.  Good ju-ju all around!  

Using the Wiseguy Cookbook, written by Henry Hill (the guy that Goodfellas is based on), I made (with some small changes) Stuffed Shells with Tomato Mint Sauce.  I've always wanted to make stuffed shells, which are one of my Mom's specialties.  The mint in the sauce is what really sold me on this recipe.


Stuffed Shells with Tomato Mint Sauce

16 jumbo shells

for the sauce
2 tablespoons olive oil
5 garlic cloves, minced
28 ounce can of crushed tomatoes
28 ounce can of tomato sauce
1/4 cup fresh mint leaves From the plant on my porch!
2 teaspoons dried parsley During my next trip to Home Depot I'll get a parsley plant!
Salt and pepper to taste

for the filling
15 ounce container ricotta cheese I used part-skim ricotta
2 cups shredded mozzarella cheese
1 cup grated Parmesan cheese (plus 1/4 cup more for topping)
1 large egg, beaten
1 tablespoon dried parsley
Salt & pepper

Cook the shells until barely al dente and drain well.  Mom told me to lay them out flat to prevent them from sticking, so I did.  

for the sauce
In a large skillet, heat olive oil over medium-low heat.  Add garlic and cook briefly, stirring.  Add the crushed tomatoes and tomato sauce and stir well.  Add mint and parsley, salt and pepper.  Cook over medium-high heat until sauce begins to bubble.  Stir well, then lower to a simmer.  Cook for 30 minutes while you stuff the shells.

Preheat oven to 350 F.

for the filling
Combine cheeses (ricotta, mozzarella, and Parmesan) in a large bowl and add beaten egg, parsley, and salt and pepper.

Then, mix thoroughly.

Spread a small amount of tomato sauce over the bottom of your fancy new casserole dish enough to hold the shells in a single layer.  Fill shells with the ricotta mixture and place in dish.  

Top with remaining sauce and sprinkle with Parmesan cheese.

Bake for 20 minutes until heated through.  Mangia!

These shells were amazing and the sauce was even better!  I'll never make sauce without mint again, no lie.  The mint was such a refreshing pop of flavor in the sauce and really added to the overall taste of the dish.  My Mom's stuffed shells have spinach in them and I didn't miss it at all.   Mom, if you're reading this, forget the spinach!  The three cheeses were such a great combination, tucked so neatly inside the shells.  

The photos only show 1 of the 2 trays that were made!  Using an entire box of shells was far too much.  I now have plain, cooked, non-stuffed shells, in addition to many, many leftover stuffed shells.  This recipe is going in the favorites, thanks Henry Hill!  All my life I wanted to be a gangster...


  1. The sauce and the shells were amazing! When you said you were making stuffed shells you definitely "made me an offer I couldn't refuse". I can't wait until part 2 and 3 of the Godfather!

    Also the strawberries are my new favorite thing.

  2. Deanna, you're too funny! I'm glad you enjoyed the food and movie selection. For breakfast this morning I had strawberries and wanted to spruce them up, but thought that was too much for 8 am :)



  4. Nooooooo! They were great without spinach.